Welding apparatus



June 8, 1954 R. H. MCDANIEL 2,680,797

WELDING APPARATUS Filed March 19, 1952 3 Sheets-Sheet l IN VENTOR A ORNEYS June 8, 1954 R, H. MCDANIEL WELDING APPARATUS 3 Sheets-Sheet 2 Filed March 19, 1952 June 8, 1954 R. H. M DANIEL 2,680,797

WELDING APPARATUS Filed March 19, 1952 3 Sheets-Sheet 5 INVENTOR BY M %9$ m ATTORNEYS ll m2 I z 1 w 5 A.

our

Patented June 8, 1954 WELDING APPARATUS Rankin H. McDaniel, Vista, Califl, assignor to Solar Aircraft Company, San Diego, Calif., a corporation of California Application March 19, 1952, Serial No. 277,443

1 Claim. 1

The present invention relates to improvements in the art of securing to metallic structures members such as studs, rivets, screws, or the like which are formed of a heat resistant metal such as stainless steel and more particularly to improvements in the art of securin to metallic structures members of this type by arc welding.

Prior to my invention it has been customary in securing such members to metallic structures by arc welding either to press the member against the surface or" the metallic structure during the time the actual arc weldin occurs or to provide an aperture in the metallic structure through which the shank of the member extends and to provide the member with an enlarged head which is fused during the welding operation to the metallic structure. Examples of stud welding apparatus operative in accordance with the former type of these prior art methods will be found in Patent No. 2,315,562, issued April 6, 1943, to J. D. Crecca et al. for Sub-Aqueous End-Welding Device; Patent No. 2,451,190, issued October 12, 1948, to F. W. l-mderson for Stud Welding Gun; Patent No 2,474,531, issued June 28, 1949, to J. M. Keir et al. for Method of and Apparatus for Electrically Welding Studs to Surfaces, and in Patent No.

.2, l91,d'. 9, issued December 20, 1949, to E. Dash for Arc Welding of Studs. Examples of apparatus for securing members to metallic structures in the latter manner will be found in Patent No. ,394,625, issued February 12, 1946, to A. C. McSann et al. for Welding Apparatus, and in Patent No. 2,458,928, issued January 11, 1949, to P, E. for Welding Fixture.

These prior art methods or" and apparatus for securing members such as studs, rivets, screws or the like to metallic structures by arc welding have proved to be unsatisfactory when such members must be formed of a heat resistant metal. such stainless steel.

in recent years much time and effort has been expended in an effort to achieve a satisfactory and inexpensive manner of securing to metallic structures members such as screws, studs, rivets similar members, which are form d of heat resistant metals such as stainless steel. Various combinations or" pressure, heat, and resistance we sang have been tried for this purpose but none have produced completely satisfactory results because icy have failed to produce a satisfactory bond between the member and metallic structure, have involved the useof elaborate and expensive equipment, and have threatened damage to the metallic structure especially in instances where space limitations are critical.

In securin members of this type which are formed of a heat resistant metal to a metallic structure, better welds are achieved when the molten metal is shielded by an inert gas. The Dash patent, aforesaid, is one example of the apparatus developed in the past for applying shielded are methods to stud welding.

Prior to my invention the shielding of the arc in stud welding by a stream of inert gas has produced certain imperfections in the resultant weld which weaken the bond between the stud and the metallic structure to which it is secured. I have found that these imperfections are caused by the lateral spreading of the molten metal, under the influence of the inert gas pressure and by the entrainment of particles of molten metal in the inert gas stream.

A further disadvantage of the prior art methods and apparatus for securing studs and the like to metallic structures by shielded arc welding has been the tendency toward arcing between the stud and the surrounding shield. This tendency has resulted primarily from the necessity in prior art methods and devices that the stud project up into the shield for substantially the entire length of the stud.

A major object of my invention is to provide an apparatus for securin members formed of heat resistant metal to a metallic structure by welding in which means are provided for properly aligning and spacin a welding electrode relative to the portion of the member to be fused in which means are provided for so blanketing the molten metal durin welding with an inert gas that the molten metal is not displaced by the gas.

It is, accordingly, a further object of my invention of primary importance to provide a novel and improved method by which members such as studs, rivets, screws or the like which are made of deformation and heat resistant metals such as stainless steel can be rapidly and inexpensively secured to a metallic structure.

A further object of primary importance of my invention is to provide an improved apparatus for securing members such as studs, screws, rivets or the like to a metallic structure by are welding in the presence of an inert gas by which the how of the shielding inert gas is so controlled that the entrainment of molten metal particles in the inert gas stream and lateral displacement of molten metal by the inert gas are substantially eliminated.

More specifically, it is an object of my invention to provide a novel and improved method of acceptor? ings, it is therein seen that the disclosed welding apparatus embodying the principles of my invention comprises, in general, a base 25, a welding torch support bracket 22 of generally platelike construction pivotally mounted at one end upon the base 2%, a welding torch assembly 2 3 reciprocably mounted at the opposite end of the sup port bracket 22 for translatory movement along a path parahel to the pivot axis of the bracket 22 on base 29, and a workpiece hold down assembly 26 disposed on the base structure 2! beneath the arcuate path of movement of the welding torch assembl 25.

As is most clearly shown in Figure 2, the base as is supported upon spaced legs 28. The bracket 22 is fixed to a tubular member to which is rotatably received upon a shaft 32 that is fixed at its lower end to the base it in a mounting block 33 thereon.

Torch mounting The welding torch assembly 24 is reciprocably mounted upon the bracket 22 at its free or opposite end by a pair of spaced collars 3d and 36 the bores of which are coaxially aligned and each of which is provided with a bifurcated projection 31 which straddles the adjacent edge of bracket 22 and which is suitably secured to bracket 22 as by screws 38.

As illustrated in Figure 2, the welding torch assembly Ed is shown in its lower or welding position. The welding torch assembly 24 includes a generally tubular member 39 which is axially slidably received through the bores of collars 34 and 35. The vertical reciprocation of w lding torch assembly 24 as guided by collars 35 and 35 is controlled by a handle 46 which is pivotally mounted upon the bracket 22 by a pivot pin 42 fixed thereto intermediate the collars 8d and 3%. Handle 68 straddles the member as is most clearly shown in Figure 3, and is operatively connected thereto by pin and slot connections formed by pins id fixed relative to the welding head assembly 24 which engage slots 35 in the handle 4% A split collar surrounds member Sid intermediate collars 3d and 85 and is fixed thereto by a clamping screw 52. The pins le, which are fixed in diametrically opposed radial extending positions in the split collar engage the slots @6 of the opposite arms of the handle all to form the pin and slot; connection.

The welding torch assembly 24 is normally biased upwardly from the position shown in Figure 2 by a compr sion spring 54, shown in its compressed condition, which abuts at its lower end upon the top surface of collar 3% and at its upper end inst the lower face or" the collar to fixed to the it of the welding torch assembly. in operation, torch 2 i is lowered to its welding position by the operators pulling down handle it and automatically returned by the action of spring Torch structure The structure of the welding torch assembly 24 is best illustrated in Figure e, wherein the lower portion thereof is shown in cross section. The welding torch assembly consists primarily of a gas nozzie a cooling jacket 52, an electrode $3, an electrode holder t t, and a sleeve 66, formed of insulating material such as lviicarta, which connects these components to the tubular member 38 which forms the main body of the welding torch assembly 2d.

In assembly, the upper end of sleeve is is threaded onto the lower portion of the tubular member 39 as indicated at B1. A coupling 68 is threadedly received within the sleeve 66 below the threaded connection 61. Electrical connection is made from a conventional arc welding power supply to the coupling liil via the wires I?! which extend downwardly through the tubular member 39.

The electrode holder (it is a sleeve of longitudinally split construction by which it can be operated to grip or release the electrode 63 within the welding torch assembly 24. The electrode holder 64 is formed at its upper end with an external bevel H which projects into a truncated conical recess '52 formed in the lower face of the coupling 58 and at its lower end with a reduced portion "it upon which is received an insulating sleeve l4 and which projects into the upper end of the central through bore E5 of the cooling jacket 62. Holder 84 and cooling jacket 62 are formed respectively with mating conical surfaces l5 and 1'! between which an outwardly flared portion 15 of insulating sleeve i l is interposed. The clamping action of the electrode holder 66 upon the electrode 53 i controlled by wedging it between the recess 12 on coupling t8 and the flared portion 18 of insulating sleeve i i,

The water jacket 62, which is of generally hollow construction as shown at 79 to permit passage of a cooling fluid such as water therethrough, externally is threadedly connected to the lower end of the sleeve 65 as indicated at as. The clamping of the electrode 63 by holder lid is effected by re tating the water jacket 52 relative to the leeve do a quarter turn in one direction while release of electrode is effected by rotation of jacket 52 a quarter turn in the opposite direction. Rotation in said one direction will wedge the beveled end H of the electrode holder 66 tightly into the recess l2 and the flared portion in of insulator it tightly against surface '56 to clamp the electrode 63 while rotation in the opposite direction will release the wedging action and thereby free the electrode 53.

The nozzle 60 controls the iiow of inert gas around the tip of electrode 53 and over the parts of the member to be fused. Nozzle to is formed with a longitudinal bore 82, through which the electrode 63 coaxially projects, and is threadedly received within the lower end of the cooling jacket 62 as indicated at 86. Flexible inlet and outlet conduits 33 and 90 are provided for transmitting a cooling fluid such as water to and from hollow portion Ti of the cooling jacket 62.

The upper end of the tubular member 39, which is not shown in Figure 4, is sealed. A pipe 232, which extends through the sealed end of member 35 as do wires i0, extends downwardly through the bore of member 39 to a position slightly above the coupling 68 as is shown in Figure 4. inert gas is introduced into the welding torch assembly 2d through this pipe 92. The inert gas flows into the bore of the tubular member 39, through the central aperture 93 or" the coupling as, along the longitudinal split 9% of the electrode holder 64, through the hollow central bore of the water jacket 62 through the bore 82 of the nozzle Bil.

Nozzle structure The structure of the nozzle to and the manner in which it controls the flow of gas is best understood by reference to Figures 4 to 6 inclusive. As is shown in Figure .5, a plurality of preferably radially extending and equiangularly spaced holes 96, which communicate between bore 82 and the atmosphere surrounding nozzle 66, are formed through the wall of the nozzle 60 to permit egress of the inert gas therefrom at points above the lower end thereof.

In Figure 4;, a metallic structure or work piece 98 and a member ills such as a stud, which is provided with a projection m2 extending through an aperture of the work piece 98, are illustrated in phantom lines to show the interrelation to the electrode 53 and the end of nozzle 69 when the welding torch assembly 24 is in its operative or welding position prior to the initiation of the are. As will be noted in Figure l, holes 86 are located above the level of the top of the projection I02 on member Hi9 so that there is no tendency toward entrainment of molten metal from projection l 32 in the inert gas discharged therethrough during the actual welding operation.

The particular form of nozzle Gil illustrated in Figure 4 is particularly adapted for use in close corners conditions such as in securing studs to a workpiece of angular cross section closely adjacent the angle thereof but is not limited to such use. To facilitate its use for this purpose, a segmental portion of the body of nozzle St has been cut away l aving a flat face H33. struction, a stud such as we can be secured to an angular workpiece such as Gil closely adjacent its vertical wall without misalignment of the electrode 63 relative the projection Hi2.

As can best be seen by reference to Figures 4 and 6, a portion of the end face of the nozzle 60 has been removed so that when the welding torch assembly 24 is lowered into its operative position, the end face of nozzle to abuts against the workpiece 98 only along the arcuate end face portion I04. End face portion EM serves as a lower limit stop for the torch assembly 24 to accurately position the lower end of electrode 63 relative to the adjacent end of projection I02. The end face of the nozzle 59 is cut away so that it will contact the workpiece Q8 only along a small sector and thus prevent excessive cooling of the workpiece at the side the projection Hi2 adjacent the center of workpiece 98 while providing the necessary cooling effect for the workpiece 93 at the side of projection Hi2 adjacent the edge.

By this nozzle construction, the inert gas flowing downwardly through the bore t2 of the nozzle (it! will blanket the projection m2 of the member Hit and the surrounding portion of the work piece es, a major portion of the inert gas being discharged through the holes 96 and the remainder thereof passing through the continuous arcuate opening formed between the cut back end of the nozzle 66 and the adjacent portion of the work piece. Since the opening formed between the work piece 98 and the end of the nozzle 60 is a continuous opening rather than small spaced apertures, the portion of the inert gas passing therethrough will flow smoothly from the nozzle 6d without forming jets of gas which tend to entrain the molten metal of the projection therein. The major portion of the gas blanketing projection W2 will iiow upwardly in opposition to the force of gravity and be discharged through holes 95 due to the pressure differential resulting from the flow of gas through holes 96.

This improved nozzle construction permits the formation of a blanketing layer of inert gas over the projection m2 during the period of fusion thereof and the continuous introduction and discharge of inert gas from such blanketing layer without producing displacement of the molten metal during welding by the gas or entrainment By this conof metallic particles therein, discharge of the inert gas being primarily effected in opposition to the force of gravity through openings 96 and secondarily through the continuous arcuate opening between the work piece and nozzle and face.

A modified form of welding torch nozzle is illustrated in Figure 7. This nozzle I H) is adapted for general use in securing members such as stud I E2 to a work piece or metallic structure I I4 at locations where no close corner conditions exist. In this form of nozzle, the nozzle I I0 when in its welding position abuts against the work piece H4 as a lower limit stop for the torch 24 along its entire continuous end face I I6. A plurality equiangularly spaced apertures IIB are formed through the wall of the nozzle M0 to permit the discharge of the inert gas therefrom. The inert gas, as in nozzle 56 of Figure 4, flows downwardly through the central bore I20 of the nozzle H6 around the centrally disposed electrode E22. In this form of the invention, the inert gas flows downwardly around the electrode 522, a portion forming the outer layer adjacent the wall of bore I20 passing outwardly from nozzle Ill} through holes lit, and the remainder flowing downwardly to form a blanketing layer over the projection of the member H2 and the surrounding portion of the work piece [I4 confined within the bore me.

This remaining portion will flow outwardly toward the wall of bore i223 and then upwardly for discharge through holes H8. In this form of nozzle the major portion of the inert gas flows downwardly, reverses its direction of flow below the level of the apertures 5 l8 and then flows upwardly and out through the apertures 8 I8. Since the apertures IIS are located above the level of the molten metal formed during the passage of electric current, the gas which contacts the molten metal flows upwardly toward the discharge apertures !!8 in opposition to the gravitational effects thereon thus preventing the entrainment of molten metallic particles in the gas. The smooth continuous blanketing effect of the gas contacting the molten metal, not being in the form of jets at the level of the molten metal, has no tendency to displace the molten metal laterally of the weld as in prior art devices.

Figure 8 illustrates the relationship of the nozzle EH2, the electrode E22, the work piece H4, and the member A i2 after completion of the weld.

Figure 9 illustrates a still further form of nozzle which is adapted for use in certain corner conditions where a nozzle of the type illustrated in Figures 4 to 6 would not be suitable. In this figure the nozzle it"? differs from the nozzle Ilil shown in Figures 7 and 8 in that an inclined planar surface lit, which is normal to the section plane of Figure 9, is formed thereon to permit positioning of the electrode i23 over the projection of a member i352 located more closely adjacent the corner of a workpiece 32 having a high side wall it than would be possible with the nozzles 68 or Hi In this construction the planar surface 26 should be so formed on the nozzle that it cooperates with the workpiece to so align the electrode E28 relative to the projection of the member its that the axis of the electrode 28 inter ects the of the projection of the member i355; at the end of the electrode. When thus positioned, a uniform arc will be formed to effect proper fusion of the projection and surrounding portion of the workpiece I32 without any tendency toward arc formation between the nozzle I24 and the electrode I 28. In this form of nozzle I24 the pattern of inert gas flow is substantially the same as that in nozzle 6D. The outer layer of the inert gas flows downwardly along the wall of bore I34 of nozzle I24 and outwardly through the apertures I36 which are equiangularly spaced about the axis of the bore I 34. The central portion of the inert gas stream flows downwardly to form a blanketing layer over the projection of member I and the surrounding portion of workpiece I32 and a portion thereof then flows outwardly through the opening formed between the end face of the nozzle I24 and the adjacent portion of the workpiece I32. The remainder of this central portion of the inert gas stream will reverse its direction of flow and be discharged through apertures I35 due to the lower pressure at that point resulting from the rapid flow of gas through apertures I36 as in the previous nozzle embodiments. The first mentioned portion of the inert gas blanketing the projection flows smoothly and uniformly outwardly through the opening formed between the end face of a tip I24 and the workpiece I32 without the entrainment of molten metallic particles in the gas stream.

Work piece hold down mechanism The illustrated form of workpiece hold down mechanism 25, shown generally in Figures 1 and 2 and in detail in Figures 11 and 12, is adapted to hold a workpiece of right angular cross sectional configuration, such as the workpiece 98 shown in Figure s. It will he understood that the details of this mechanism can be Varied to accommodate workpieces of different form without departing from the principles of my inven tion in its broadest aspects. The illustrated mechanism comprises a plurality of stud holder assemblies I49 mounted on a plate I42 which is secured to the main base 26 of the apparatus. Assemblies Hill are so disposed on the plate I42 and of such construction that each is adapted to hold one of a plurality of members I80 such as studs, rivets, etc. below the arcuate path of movement of the welding torch assembly 24 about the axis of shaft 32. The workpiece 98, which is appropriately apertured to receive the projections on members Ifiil, is placed over-the studs and held in position during the welding operation against a plurality of arcuately disposed back up studs I44 by end clamps I 46 and I48 and pneumatically actuated hold down clamps I52, I52, and IE4.

The end clampsl4ii and I48 each comprise a clamping block I56 guided for translatorymovement by guideways I58 and IE0 along paths radially disposed relative to the pivot axis of the bracket 22. The blocks I56 are actuated along such paths by screws r52 which are threadedly received in aligned blocks I64 fixed to the plate I42 and which are connected to the blocks I 56 by rotary connection I66. A handle I68 is fixed upon the outer end of screw I62 to facilitate its rotary manipulation. The end faces of the blocks I56 are provided with a transverse groove Ilii which is adapted to straddle the edge of a workpiece. The workpiece is placed in position over the studs and firmly wedged in position by the end clamps I and I48 against the arcuately disposed back-up studs I44.

The hold down clamps I58, I52 and I54 are pivotally mounted about a common axis normal to the pivot axis of bracket 22, clamp I being pivotally mounted upon a shaft II2 supported between mounting blocks I74 and i'It, which are fixed to the plate I42, clamp I52 being pivotally mounted upon a pair of stub shafts I78 and I80 mounted in coaxial alignment in blocks Hit and I82 respectively, and clamp I54 is pivotally mounted upon a shaft I84 which is supported by blocks I82 and block I8E which are fixed to the plate I42.

Pneumatic motors I88, we and I92, which are pivotally mounted below plate I42 about a common axis parallel to the common pivot axis of clamps use, I52 and I54 are connected respectively to actuate clamps E50, I52 and I54. As is best shown in Figures 11 and 12 in reference to motor Itfi, each of these motors preferably consists of a cylinder having a resiliently biased piston therein, which is not shown, a piston rod I24, which is connected to the piston and projects from the cylinder at one end, and a fluid connection I96 provided for the controlled introduction of fiuid into the cylinder at the opposite end. As is shown in Figure 12, the motors are pivotally mounted between mounting blocks its and 299, which are fixed to the bottom of the plate I42 as by screws 2&2 and dowels 28 i, stub shafts 2655 and 228 being provided for this purpose.

As is best shown in Figure 11, a yoke 2 I E], which is fixed to the upper end of the piston rod I94, is pivotally connected to the outer end of each clamp, such as IE2, by a pivot pin 2I2. By this construction, after the workpiece is placed in position and clamped at its ends against the back up studs I44, the pneumatic motors I88, I94 and I32 are simultaneously actuated by the introduction of fluid through the fluid connections I95 to cause the hold down clamps I50, I52 and I54 to pivot about their common pivot axis to firmly clamp the workpiece in position against the blocks I43 fixed to the plate I42, Fluid pressure on motors I83, I and I92 is maintained until the welding operation is completed.

As is best shown in Figures 11 and 11A, the stud positioning assemblies I46 are each provided with a stud receiving recess 241i} and a through threaded aperture 242 coaxially aligned therewith. A. spring assembly 244, which is threaded through the opening 242 has a resiliently biased projection 245 which projects upwardly into the recess 249 to resiliently abut against the bottom end of a stud, screw or rivet placed in the recess 240 to bias it outwardly thereof. At diametrically opposed sides of the recess :40 resiliently biased gripping elements, such as 246, are provided to hold the stud within the recess 24d and in the case of diametrally apertured studs such as H2 .and I39 of Figures 7 to 9 inclusive to accurately align such apertures relative to the workpiece to which the stud is to be secured.

Torch alignment relative to the workpiece and members As is best shown in Figures 1 and 2, a plate 252 is mounted upon the base 25 in spaced parallel relation thereto beneath the path of movement of the bracket 22 and projecting over plate I42. This plate 252 is suitably supported by mounting blocks 254 and 258 and suitably secured to the base as by screws 258 which, in addition, hold the plate I42 in position upon the base 23. The top surface of the plate 252 is formed with a plurality of recesses 260 which are arcuately disposed about the pivot axis of the bracket 22 and which are like in number to the number or" studs to be secured to the workpiece.

A block 262 is fixed to the bottom edge of the bracket 22 at its free end for movement therewith over the arcuately disposed recesses 26!). As is best shown in Figure 10, which is a sectional view through the block 262 taken along the line Iii-4i] of Figure 1, block 262 is formed with a through bore 262 in which is mounted a ball 265 and a compression spring 268 compressed against the top of ball 26% by a screw 21B threadedly received within the top end of a bore 264. The ball 266, as is shown in Figure 10, is suitably positioned to engage the several notches 260 formed in the top surface of the plate 262 to coact therewith to form a detent to accurately align the torch 24 relative to the stud holding recess 24!) of the blocks Mil.

Operation ing notch 2%. Handle 46 is then pulled down to depress the torch 2d to the position shown in Figure 2, bringing nozzle to into contact with the workpiece $28 as shown in Figure 4. It should be noted that in this position, the nozzle completely encloses the head I02 of stud Hit.

A foot lever, not shown, controls the flow of I electricity through wires 2% and the flow of inert gas through tube 92 simultaneously so that as the arc is struck between the electrode 63 and the stud head 182, the head is bathed or blanketed in inert gas which flows through tube 92, around the stud head and out throughholes 96 and the cutaway end portion of the nozzle 66, thus eliminating ambient atmosphere which, if allowed to contact the stud while it is in a molten state or still extremely hot, would have a deleterious effect, causing cracks in the weldment.

A control box, not shown, controls the time of the arc and the time of the gas how, the latter lasting approximately a second longer than the arc time to insure protection of the hot, newly formed head. Upon completion of the first heading operation, handle it is released, spring 54 raises the torch 24. Torch 24 is repositioned as before above the next stud to be welded. It should be noted that positioning the electrode in the electrode holder need be carried out only after a large number of weldments have been accomplished as the electrode 63 is of the type known as non-consumable electrodes.

When all studs I00 on the workpiece 98 have been headed, clamps I50, I52, I54 and end clamps I46 and H18 are released, the workpiece is re- 12 moved and a new set of studs and a workpiece are positioned on the backup or cooling block M2.

As can be seen most clearly in Figures 4 and 6, the nozzle 60 contacts the workpiece 98 only over a small area where the greatest amount of heat from the arc must be removed as quickly as possible, The remainder of the nozzle tip is cut away, not only so too much heat will not be removed, but also to allow a uniform flow of inert gas over the stud head.

It is obvious that inexpensive templates and backup bars can be made to automatically position the torch to the workpiece in a variety of forms. It also can be seen that this method can be used to head studs and rivets horizontally or vertically, it being important in vertical usage only to more closely control the time limitations of the arc.

The invention may be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the spirit or essential characteristics thereof. The present embodiments are therefore to be considered in all respects as illustrative and not restrictive, the scope of the invention being indicated by the appended claim rather than by the foregoing description, and all changes which come within the meaning and range of equivalency of the claim are therefore intended to be embraced therein.

What is claimed and desired to be secured by the United States Letters Patent is:

A device for securing a plurality of studs to a base member, comprising, in combination, a base, a support mounted on said base for pivotal movement about an axis, a welding torch mounted on said support for reciprocation along an axis parallel to the support pivot axis, means arcuately disposed on said base beneath said welding torch for holding a plurality of studs in spaced relation on said base beneath the arcuate path of movement of said torch about said pivot axis, detent means on said base and said support for aligning said torch with each of said studs, and hold down means for clamping an appropriately apertured base member to said base over said studs.

References Cited in the file of this patent UNITED STATES PATENTS Number Name Date 1,410,421 Steele Mar, 21, 1922 1,718,715 Spencer June 25, 1929 1,873,619 Mojonnier Aug. 23, 1932 2,136,619 Johnson Nov. 15, 1938 2,405,033 Grimes July 30, 1946 2,550,495 Pilia Apr. 24, 1951 2,610,278 Graham Sept. 9, 1952 

